What you can understand in 30 seconds
- The target is not “use IP communication” but “have IP communication functions.” Even if it is not wired, disabled in settings, or permanently disabled at shipment, it is still covered (Q2–Q4)
- The wording difference from the public materials’ phrase "using IP communications" is a variation in expression and is "essentially synonymous" (Q5)
- IP/non-IP comparison, IEC 62443 comparison, and alternative measure comparison—there is no comparison material from the perspective of making requirements (Q9, Q10, Q14, Q18)
- Impact assessment and relief procedures are handled not in documents but in conversation and case-by-case consultation (Q12, Q15, Q17)
- The reason for imposing ★1 on solar PV and battery storage in general was to confirm that it was not impossible to make it a requirement, and then decide (Q25)
- The review practice is left to the general transmission and distribution utilities, and the response is withheld (Q21). As for the possibility of verification by third parties, there are no plans to ensure it (Q27)
- The content of the ★1 compliance criteria is close to putting into writing matters that major products already implement—saying that it is an improvement because it is the minimum does not prove any additional burden
- Without a label, new grid interconnection is impossible = a de facto market entry condition. At the same time, the review criteria, reasons for decisions, and relief channels remain undeveloped
Explanatory video — Japanese, English, and Chinese
"Verification is not guaranteed," "there are no comparison materials," and "the review criteria are left to each company"—the facts confirmed in the full 28-question responses, and the structure in which voluntary certification turns into de facto regulation, are explained in videos in Japanese, English, and Simplified Chinese.
| Language | Title | On-site viewing | YouTube |
|---|---|---|---|
| Japanese | The truth behind JC-STAR system interconnection mandatory implementation — a dissection of the Agency for Natural Resources and Energy's 28-question answers [verification is not guaranteed] | Reproduction | Watch |
| English | Grid Mandate Autopsy — METI's 28 Answers on Japan's JC-STAR Grid Rule | Reproduction | Watch |
| Simplified Chinese | JC-STAR illusion: deconstructing the July 30 grid-connection policy — a dissection of the Agency for Natural Resources and Energy's full 28-question responses | Reproduction | Watch |
There is also a short version that compresses the key points into 60 seconds: Japanese / English / Simplified Chinese.
Previous work — not scale. It is a reach structure. (Japanese, English, Chinese): Japanese / English / Simplified Chinese | Earlier work — the logical breakdown of mandatory adoption: Japanese / English / Simplified Chinese.
The entire series is collected in a playlist.
1. Background — what the three-week inquiry fixed
Fact This series of inquiries began with the public questions (8 items) on July 10, 2026. This response corresponds to the fourth round.
| date | exchange | confirmed key facts | record |
|---|---|---|---|
| 7/10 → 7/13 | 8 public questions → initial response | "The scope is determined by our agency" | initial response |
| 7/14 → 7/16 | 6-item reconfirmation → re-response | PCS with RS-485 only is out of scope. The responding division is the Power Infrastructure Development Division | re-response analysis |
| 7/16 and 7/26 | Additional inquiries Q1 to Q18 and supplemental inquiries Q19 to Q28 sent | — | cross-check inquiry |
| 7/19〜7/26 | Three inquiries to IPA (answers to all questions) | Boundary defense is not considered / label ≠ installation safety / exceptions are invisible | IPA Third Response |
| 7/30 | The Agency for Natural Resources and Energy provided written answers to all questions from Q1 to Q28 | this paper | This page |
2. First, what should be assessed
Analysis There are three points in this response that clearly differ from the previous exchanges.
- Individual responses were provided for all 28 questions. Rather than being organized as a single “submit everything to IPA” response, answers are listed by question number.
- The name of the responsible division was made clear. The body explicitly states that the response is an official reply from the Power Infrastructure Development Division. The entity responsible for the answer is no longer ambiguous.
- Facts that could be unfavorable were also acknowledged. “We do not have comparative materials” (Q14 and Q18) and “We do not plan to guarantee it” (Q27) are questions to which a non-response could also have been chosen. The fact that they were stated as-is is sincere as an administrative explanation.
I appreciate this response itself. The issue is the substance that was confirmed as a result of answering sincerely.
3. Three confirmed structures
Structure 1 — The target is not "using" but "owning." Devices that cannot communicate were also included as targets
Fact The answers to Q2 through Q4 are clear.
Even if the Ethernet port is left unconnected, disabled in settings, or permanently disabled at shipment so that physical communication is impossible, it is still subject to the requirement. On the other hand, in Q22 it was confirmed that devices that do not have IP communication functions are excluded, and that no exemption application is required.
Analysis Putting these two together, the criterion for separating the subject devices is not whether they communicate with the outside, but only whether IP functionality is mounted on the board. A device that has been permanently disabled and a device that has no port from the start are both unreachable from the network. However, the former requires a label and the latter does not — the response does not explain which cyber risk is reduced by obtaining a label for a device that cannot communicate.
Important Furthermore, in Q5, the relationship between the wording “products that use IP communication,” which has been consistently used in public materials, and the current “have IP communication functions” was summarized as “in principle synonymous, despite some variation in wording in the materials.” A business operator who reads “use” may understand that if it is not used, it is outside the scope. If the wording that defines the scope of an obligation can be dismissed as mere “variation,” then what should business operators read to know their obligations? The issue of predictability has deepened one level further, from the absence of a definition to instability in wording.
In addition, the determination for individual devices (the proviso in Q2 and Q6) was said to be “please confirm with IPA.” Taken together with the July 13 response that “the scope is determined by our agency,” this creates a division of roles in which the principle of scope is set by our agency, and individual application is handled by IPA, but as the entity responsible for determinations that affect whether grid interconnection is possible, it remains unresolved.
Structure 2 — There is no document for comparative examination
Fact The responses to the eight questions asking about the existence of technical review materials (Q7 through Q14) and the impact assessment (Q15 through Q18) are summarized into the following three types.
- “We do not have any” — comparison between IP and non-IP communication (Q9), comparison with IEC 62443, Zone & Conduit, and boundary defense (Q10 and Q14), and comparison with alternative measures (Q18). It was clearly stated that there are no comparative materials from the perspective of making the requirement.
- "Please refer to the WG materials" — threat model (Q7), risk analysis (Q8), evaluation of attack cases (Q11), effectiveness evaluation (Q13), and supporting documents (Q28). No specific document names or sections are indicated; this is a blanket reference to the public deliberation materials.
- "In conversations" — the examination of bypass configurations (Q12), market impact assessment (Q15), and the mechanisms for foreseeability and objections (Q17) were handled through conversations and case-by-case consultations with industry groups and individual operators, rather than through documents.
Analysis There is no document that examined consistency with the international standard (IEC 62443), no comparative document for alternative options, and impact assessment and relief procedures depend on "conversations" — this is not our speculation, but the documented response of the division in charge of requirements formulation. It has become part of the official record that a requirement placed at the gateway to market entry for grid interconnection was adopted with zero comparative review documents.
Structure 3 — No one verifies installation safety
Fact IPA has already stated that having obtained the "conformity label" does not indicate that something is "safely installed and operated" (F4). Then who in the interconnection process checks the safety of installation and operation? Here are the responses, laid out together.
- Q26 (whether the interconnection requirement checks product conformity or installation safety) — instead of answering the either-or question, it says, "We require conformity with JC-STAR★1 ... in order to enhance effectiveness." The only item identified as the subject of confirmation was product conformity only.
- Q21 (whether the review checks the configuration diagram) — "As the review practice is carried out by the general transmission and distribution utility in the relevant area for each case, we will refrain from responding at our agency."
- Q27 (how foreseeability and verifiability are ensured when exceptions cannot be distinguished) — "We do not plan to ensure third-party verifiability."
Analysis This is where the overall structure of the system closes in on itself. The label does not indicate installation safety (IPA). What the requirement checks is only product conformity (Q26). The design of the review is outside the scope of the division that created the requirement (Q21). No mechanism is being created for a third party to verify the actual state of the label (Q27). In other words, there is no entity in the制度 that confirms the safety of the system as one connected to the grid. Even so, the label is required even for devices that cannot communicate. There is no document, as shown in Figure 2, that explains what is actually being protected.
4. Reason for the decision that it is not impossible to make a requirement
Fact For wind power, early application is limited to boundary gateways and firewalls, while for solar power and battery storage, ★1 is mandatory for all control systems with communication functions — the answer to Q25, which asked why this difference in approach exists, is recorded in the original text as follows.
Analysis The reason given was that it was confirmed to be something that could be implemented, and not for security reasons. If a boundary-device-focused approach is feasible for wind power, then there should be a technical basis for not adopting it for solar power, which has the same network structure. The response did not show that basis, and instead cited only feasibility through consultation with the industry. "Whether it can be imposed" and "whether it should be imposed" are different questions. It has been confirmed in the division's own words that only the former was checked.
Relatedly, for Q19 (whether excluding devices connected via a gateway assumes the effect of boundary defense), the response did not answer whether that assumption exists, and only said, "Gateways are included among devices with communication functions, and are included in the target products." It has been confirmed that the gateway itself is covered, but the treatment of devices under the gateway, and the relationship with the definition in the February 2026 public materials ("devices connected without going through a gateway, etc."), remain unanswered.
5. The actual effect of ★1 — what does “minimum” add
Fact The only positive reason the Agency for Natural Resources and Energy repeated across the 28 questions was, "We will use the JC-STAR★1 system, which exists as a unified minimum standard for all IoT products, to enhance effectiveness" (Q14, Q16, Q18, Q20, Q26). This explanation rests on the premise that even a minimum standard is an improvement over requiring nothing. We will examine that premise from the substance of the standard.
The fact required by ★1 compliance criteria is the elimination of common default passwords that are easy to guess, ensuring means for software updates, and establishing a contact point and policy for vulnerability response—basic product security requirements. Compliance is confirmed by the manufacturer’s self-declaration of conformity, and there is no third-party testing (thorough investigation report in publicly available IPA materials).
analysisThese items are already implemented by major PCS, EMS, and others currently distributed in JapanDocumentation of practices already generally implementedis close to that. Products that cannot change passwords or do not have update methods are hardly distributed in the current market. In other words, the additional security that ★1 requirement setting adds to the market is extremely limited. The explanation that "it improves things because it is the minimum standard"Only when products that do not meet the standard actually occupy a substantial share of the marketIt is possible to conclude, but the Agency for Natural Resources and Energy has not presented materials showing that reality anywhere in the 28 questions (Q13 and Q14 are a blanket reference to the study group materials and "we do not have comparative materials").
FactThe May 2024 attack on remote monitoring equipment, which is said to have triggered the requirements, was, according to public information, an incident in which equipment directly exposed to the internet and left vulnerable despite a patch being available was compromised. In response to Q24, which asked whether the Agency referred to the intrusion route investigation for this incident when considering the requirements, the Agency answered with a blanket reference without specifying the document name.
AnalysisDirect exposure, unpatched status, and operational deficiencies—all of the elements that made up this incident—occur independently of whether the product had a ★1 label at the time of shipment. As IPA has made clear, the label does not indicate that the product is “safely installed and operated” (F4), and ★1 is in fact designed on the assumption of external direct exposure (F1). In other words, the areas where improvement is actually needed—exposure, configuration, and operation—are outside the scope of ★1 evaluation, while the areas ★1 evaluates—the basic hygiene of the product—are already largely satisfied. “It is a minimum, so it improves things” does not prove any additional effect for these two reasons.
The effect of the requirements that can be said with certainty from public evidence is not improved security, but the procedural act of obtaining a label and the exit from the market of products that cannot complete that process. No material submitted in response to the 28 questions showed that the former produces any practical benefit beyond the latter. Additional confirmation Q36 asks the Agency to identify this point in its own words—if it can name the “★1 requirements that major products do not currently meet,” the additional effect becomes concrete; if it cannot, then the effect of the requirements is confirmed to be only procedure and exit.
6. Conversion of voluntary certification into de facto regulation and administrative procedure
FactJC-STAR is, by design, a voluntary conformity label. Meanwhile, the Agency for Natural Resources and Energy maintains the policy of requiring products that have obtained ★1 for grid interconnection technical requirements (Q16 and Q26), and except for non-IP equipment, it also covers equipment that has been permanently disabled (Q2 to Q4).
AnalysisIf there is no label, new grid interconnection cannot be made, and if interconnection cannot be made, power generation business and product sales cannot in practice be established. Even if the name is voluntary, in economic and legal effect the ★1 label functions as a mandatory condition for market entry and grid interconnection. This is not “policy use of voluntary certification,” but the conversion of voluntary certification into a de facto regulatory requirement.
FactAs for the operational framework as regulation, the current answers established the following. The review criteria and verification method are “implemented by the general transmission and distribution utility,” so the Agency withheld its answer (Q21). The criteria for determining economic disadvantage, public disclosure, predictability, and the mechanism for objections are “to be discussed on a case-by-case basis” (Q17). There is “no plan to ensure” third-party verifiability regarding the invisibility of exceptional acquisitions (Q27).
Legal assessment (conditional)The Administrative Procedure Act requires, for dispositions on applications, the establishment and publication of review criteria (Article 5) and the presentation of reasons when an application is denied (Article 8). Although grid interconnection review is formally part of the contract practice of the general transmission and distribution utility, the requirements are established based on the organization of national councils and study groups and are applied uniformly nationwide. Here, consider the case where all of the following premises are proven.
- (i) Refusal of grid interconnection on the grounds of not having obtained ★1 may be evaluated as a disposition or a public judgment equivalent thereto, and the Administrative Procedure Act or its intent may apply
- (ii) At the time of enforcement, review criteria have not been set or published (the content of the answers to Q21 and Q17 remains unchanged)
- (iii) The presentation of reasons for rejection and the route for re-evaluation and objection are not in place (Q17 remains at "case-by-case consultation")
- (iv) No reasonable basis has been shown for excluding equivalent or superior alternative protective measures (Q18 remains "we do not have comparative materials")
Under this premise, the denial is assessed as unlawful in light of the requirements of the Administrative Procedure Act and the general principles of administrative law (the principle of equality and the principle of proportionality). This is not a statement of possibility, but a conditional legal consequence fixed by the premise. Conversely, if the Agency for Natural Resources and Energy resolves (ii) to (iv) before enforcement, this consequence can be avoided. Which premise does it plan to resolve—that is what additional confirmation Q37 asks. The current answers (Q17, Q21, and Q27) do not indicate any plan to resolve any of the premises.
Not establishedNote that the dispositive nature of a grid interconnection refusal (premise i) is a point of legal interpretation, and this paper does not assert that it applies. However, if dispositive nature is denied, it would mean that “entry conditions set by the government are being left to review by a private party to which the Administrative Procedure Act does not apply,” and the absence of due process becomes even more serious. Either way, the problem itself—no review criteria, no statement of reasons, and no remedy—does not disappear.
7. Expected counterarguments and remaining issues
AnalysisWe set out, in the strongest possible form, the counterarguments that could be expected from the administrative side and compare them with the current answers.
| anticipated rebuttal | Scope that can be explained by objections | Issues that remain unexplained |
|---|---|---|
| There is a significant public interest objective of stable power supply | Legitimacy of purpose. Our company has also consistently supported the purpose | The legitimacy of the purpose does not substitute for the reasonableness of the means. Comparative materials for the choice of means are "not available" (Q14, Q18) |
| It is a minimum unified standard, and it is an improvement over requiring nothing | Raising the overall level when there are a considerable number of products on the market that do not meet the standard | The content of the criteria is close to codifying existing practice, and no materials showing actual noncompliance have been presented. The areas that need improvement (exposure, configuration, operation) are outside the scope of the ★1 evaluation (Chapter 5) |
| Broad administrative discretion is recognized in specialized technical judgments | The fact that there is a certain degree of discretion in setting technical requirements itself | To control discretion, materials that can trace the decision-making process are necessary. The threat model and risk analysis are only referenced in blanket form (Q7, Q8), and the reason for the decision is "not impossible to make a requirement" (Q25), so the decision-making process cannot be traced |
| Because there is an exception application, non-IP devices and others can also be accommodated | Possibility of relief in individual cases | The purpose of the exception is "prevention of business disadvantage," with no distinction by acquisition status, no publication of statistics, and verifiability "not planned to be ensured" (IPA second and third responses, Q27). Not a relief system, but invisible individual discretion |
| The review practice is under the jurisdiction of general transmission and distribution operators | Explanation of the review authority for individual cases | If the entity that established the requirements does not explain the design of the review, a gap in responsibility remains between the requirements and enforcement (Q21, Q32, Q33). The existence of unified review criteria is unconfirmed |
| It is a phased introduction, and in the future ★2 and above and system requirements will also be considered | future improvement potential | Materials specifying timing do "not exist" (Q23). The current system should be evaluated based on its current design, and future discussions do not fill the present gap |
All of these objections are variations on “the purpose is correct,” “the minimum is there,” and “it will be improved in the future,” and they do not prove that the chosen means are reasonable, necessary, and fair. Not confusing this distinction—the legitimacy of the purpose and the reasonableness of the means, the minimal usefulness and the reasonableness as a mandatory entry condition—is the consistent axis of verification in this series.
8. Full text of all 28 questions and answers
Public record Received on July 30, 2026. Responses are reproduced as written in the original text, with only the Excel furigana data removed. Definitive means a clear answer directly tied to understanding of the system; Indirect means a response that does not answer the options and instead replies with references or generalities. For the full text of the questions, see the Q1–Q18 transmittal letter and the Q19–Q28 transmittal letter.
| ID | Questions (summary) and answers (original text) |
|---|---|
| Q1 | Is there an official definition of “IP communication function”“It refers to a data transmission and reception function using the Internet Protocol.” Definitive (No definition document was provided) |
| Q2 | Does this apply even if the Ethernet port is not wired“If it has IP communication functions, it is subject to the requirement regardless of whether it is used. However, please confirm with IPA whether it falls under JC-STAR★1 depending on individual conditions such as physical separation.” Definitive |
| Q3 | If IP communication is disabled in the settings“Same as above” = subject Definitive |
| Q4 | If it is permanently disabled at shipment or during installation“Same as above” = subject Definitive |
| Q5 | Are “uses IP communication” and “has IP communication” synonymous in public materials“We do not know all public materials being referred to, but where there are variations in wording in the materials, they are in principle synonymous.” Definitive |
| Q6 | Definition of “major constituent products.” Does it include PC, PLC, Logger, Gateway, and LTE router“Because it is difficult to grasp all individual system configurations, it is difficult to answer categorically, but as a grid code, we require acquisition of JC-STAR★1 for those that can obtain it. Please confirm with IPA whether each individual piece of equipment is subject to JC-STAR★1.” (No definition; no equipment-by-equipment answer) Indirect |
| Q7 | Is there threat model material when determining the scope of applicability“Please refer to the electric power subworking group materials. As for JC-STAR, please refer to IPA’s explanation of the ★1 conformity criteria and evaluation guide.” (No direct answer on whether it exists; no specific document name) Indirect |
| Q8 | Is there risk analysis material“Same as above” Indirect |
| Q9 | Is there material comparing IP communication and non-IP communication“This is not from the perspective of making JC-STAR★1 acquisition a requirement in the grid code.” Definitive |
| Q10 | Is there comparative material on IEC 62443, Zone & Conduit, and Boundary Protection“Same as above” = does not exist Definitive |
| Q11 | Is there any document evaluating that the May 2024 attack case could be prevented or mitigated by ★1"Please refer to the materials of the Power Subworking Group and the Grid Code Study Group."Indirect |
| Q12 | Did you examine a bypass configuration in which PCS is non-IP and external communication via LTE is routed through a PC"Because it is difficult to grasp every individual system configuration, we are discussing this in conversations with industry associations and individual operators."Indirect |
| Q13 | Is there any document evaluating the effect of making it a requirement"Please refer to the materials of the Power Subworking Group and the Grid Code Study Group."Indirect |
| Q14 | In that evaluation, was a comparison with perimeter defense, IEC 62443, and the like conducted"(...) From the perspective of making JC-STAR ★1 certification a requirement in the grid code, we do not have comparative materials."Confirmed |
| Q15 | Is there any document evaluating market entry, existing equipment, and manufacturer impact"We are discussing this in conversations with individual operators. As for how existing equipment is handled, please refer to the FAQ below." (link to the Agency for Natural Resources and Energy site FAQ)Indirect |
| Q16 | Is there any document that describes the institutional arrangement of treating a voluntary system as a de facto prerequisite for obtaining it"Ensuring a stable power supply is important (...) and we intend to enhance effectiveness by utilizing the JC-STAR ★1 system. As materials, please refer to the Power Subworking Group and the Grid Code Study Group materials."Indirect |
| Q17 | Are there any public criteria for judgments on economic disadvantage, foreseeability, and a mechanism for objections"We discuss these matters as needed in conversations with industry associations and individual operators."Confirmed (no materials or operational rules were presented) |
| Q18 | Is there any comparative evaluation material for alternative measures"(...) First, we intend to enhance effectiveness by utilizing JC-STAR ★1, which is the minimum security standard required for all IoT products, and we do not have comparative materials for alternative measures."Confirmed |
| Q19 | Does defining items excluded via a gateway assume the effect of perimeter defense"As for gateways, they are included in devices with communication functions and are included in the target products." (No answer on whether the premise exists. The target status of the gateway itself is confirmed)Indirect |
| Q20 | Were you aware that ★1 is not specific to power systems (IPA F2). What are the supplementary measures"We are aware of that. On that basis (...) we intend to enhance effectiveness by utilizing the JC-STAR ★1 system." (Awareness confirmed. No specific supplementary measures identified)Confirmed |
| Q21 | Does the interconnection review include a mechanism for matching the configuration diagram"As for the review practice, it is carried out by the local general transmission and distribution utility for each case, so we will refrain from responding at our agency."Confirmed |
| Q22 | Whether interconnection is permitted for devices that depend on whether an exception application can be filed for non-IP equipment"In the case of non-IP communication equipment (that does not have IP communication functions), as you understand, it is outside the scope, so we do not ask for an exception application. We leave the response to the business operator's judgment."Confirmed |
| Q23 | Is there a roadmap for ★2 or higher and system requirements?“As for the development and introduction of compliance criteria for ★2 or higher, discussions will be continued in the council and other forums going forward, and there is no document that clearly states a timing.”Confirmed |
| Q24 | Was the investigation of the intrusion route in the 2024 attack case referenced when considering the requirements?“Please refer to the materials of the Power Subworking Group.”Indirect |
| Q25 | Why was wind power focused on boundary equipment, while solar PV and battery storage were made subject to mandatory overall ★1 compliance?“After discussions with industry associations and individual businesses related to solar PV and battery storage, we confirmed that it was not impossible to make this a requirement, and decided accordingly.”Confirmed |
| Q26 | Does the connection requirement verify (a) product compliance or (b) installation safety?“As repeated, we require compliance with JC-STAR ★1, which exists as a unified minimum standard for all IoT products, and we aim to enhance the effectiveness of ensuring cybersecurity in order to secure a stable power supply.” (No direct answer to the either-or question; only product compliance was mentioned.)Indirect |
| Q27 | How will predictability and third-party verifiability be ensured on the premise that exception acquisition is not visible?“Regarding the lack of distinction between exception acquisition and normal acquisition for non-IP products, we do not plan to ensure verifiability by third parties.”Confirmed |
| Q28 | What public documents are relied on for accountability?“Materials from the Grid Working Group, the Power Subworking Group, and the Grid Code Study Group. Based on discussions in the Next-Generation Power Grid Working Group, we have decided to require JC-STAR ★1 acquisition as a grid-connection technical requirement.”Confirmed |
9. Additional confirmation Q29 to Q37
InquiryIn responses to all 28 questions, most issues were settled in writing. What remains are consistency questions newly raised by the responses themselves. The follow-up questions are narrowed to the following nine, and will be sent to the Power Infrastructure Development Division together with our thanks. Q29 to Q34 confirm the consequences of the responses, and Q35 to Q37 ask about the identification of effects and the planned development of procedures—whether the blank spaces shown in Chapters 5 and 6 will be filled in the Agency for Natural Resources and Energy's own words, or whether it will explicitly say they will not be filled.
| ID | Confirmed details | origin |
|---|---|---|
| Q29 | Specific risks expected to be reduced by obtaining ★1 for equipment that is permanently unable to communicate | Q4 |
| Q30 | Is the February 2026 material defining the scope (devices connected without GW, etc.) still valid? Are devices under the GW included | Q19 |
| Q31 | Is there a security reason for not adopting the wind-power approach for solar PV (focusing on boundary devices) | Q25 |
| Q32 | Which party in the interconnection process confirms the safety of the installation configuration and operation | Q21 and Q26 |
| Q33 | Are there review guidelines for general transmission and distribution operators (such as cross-checking configuration diagrams) | Q21 |
| Q34 | Is “no plan to ensure verifiability” an official departmental position | Q27 |
| Q35 | Is there an equivalence assessment or alternative measure that allows products without ★1 certification in equipment implementing defenses equal to or better than them | Q18 |
| Q36 | What ★1 requirements are not currently met by major PCS, EMS, etc. (identifying the improvements brought by requirement-setting) | Q13 and Q14 |
| Q37 | Will the publication of review criteria, presentation of reasons for rejection, and objection procedures be in place by enforcement | Q17, Q21, and Q27 |
full text of the transmittal letter
10. What to state, what not to state, and the direction of correction
To state it as an established fact
- It was confirmed in the division's written response that the scope of the requirements is defined by possession of IP communication functions, and that devices with permanently disabled functions are also included (Q2 to Q4).
- It was confirmed in the division's written response that there are no materials comparing perimeter defense, IEC 62443, and alternative measures from the perspective of requirements formulation (Q14 and Q18).
- What was presented as the reason for deciding to apply ★1 generally to solar PV and battery storage was a “confirmation that it was not impossible to make it a requirement,” and no security-related reason was stated (Q25).
- The arrangement that third-party verifiability regarding the invisibility of exception acquisition will “not be ensured” was recorded as the division's written response (Q27).
To state it as an assessment based on evidence
- On the public record, the rationality of the choice of means to make ★1 acquisition a mandatory grid-connection entry requirement has not been demonstrated (this is a separate issue from the legitimacy of the purpose)
- For all of the scope, exceptions, review, and relief, the level of transparency that would allow a third party to reproduce the same conclusion cannot be confirmed
- The system goes beyond a formal voluntary certification and functions as a de facto market entry and grid interconnection condition
- In light of the content of the ★1 conformity criteria, it can be reasonably inferred from public materials that the additional security imposed on the market by making the requirements mandatory is limited (Q36 confirms this with higher certainty)
Not to assert
- We do not conclude that there is no description corresponding to a threat model or risk analysis in the WG or study group materials ("there are no comparative materials" is a confirmed fact, but "nothing was examined internally" is unproven. Because of the blanket reference, continue identifying the relevant sections)
- Legal determination of intent to exclude (to conclude both the structural difference in treatment and that the basis for it has not been shown)
- Dispositional nature of a refusal to interconnect (a legal interpretation issue. The legal conclusion in Chapter 6 is conditional on fixed premises)
Direction of correction The target of criticism is not the purpose of the system but its design. Correction is not difficult——performance-based standardization to "★1or equivalent measures", allowing equivalence evaluation by IEC 62443 and similar standards, distinguishing between ordinary acquisition and exception-based acquisition, publishing unified review criteria and reasons for rejection, establishing channels for re-evaluation and objections, and periodically verifying effectiveness. Concrete alternatives centered on equipment-side configuration obligations have already been published as the "minimum duty of care" approach, and all of these are revisions that exclude no one, align with international standards, and improve consistency with the objective.
11. About quotation and reuse
The Agency for Natural Resources and Energy, Electricity Infrastructure Development Division responses to all 28 questions cited in this article are published under CC BY 4.0 as question-by-question CSV files and public reproductions of the originals (Excel and PDF). They may be freely used, including for redistribution, modification, and commercial use, provided that I-S3 Co., Ltd. and the URL of this article are clearly stated as the source. Copyright in the response text belongs to each administrative agency, and the CSV is an itemized arrangement of the responses received by question. The individual names, email addresses, and phone numbers of the government-side staff have been replaced with [omitted], while the department name, date received, and response text remain unchanged.
The text and figures may be quoted as is, provided the source is clearly stated. For reproduction or redistribution of figures and tables, please contact inquiries. If you have a different interpretation of how to read the responses, please use the same contact point. If the basis is shown, it will be added to the text.
Data file
meti_answers_28.csv— Agency for Natural Resources and Energy, Electricity Infrastructure Development Division responses: all 28 questionsipa_replies.csv— IPA Security Center responses, 19 questions across 3 rounds (attached to the first response analysis)README.txt— Column meanings, publication scope, and license
Original public copy
This is a reproduction of the received Excel file and email body, with only the individual names, email addresses, and phone numbers of the government-side staff replaced by [omitted]. The number of replaced locations is in MASKING.md.
meti_answers_20260730_masked.xlsx— Agency for Natural Resources and Energy response Original Excel (received 2026-07-30 · copy for public release)meti_answers_20260730_masked.pdf— Agency for Natural Resources and Energy response Original Excel PDF versionmeti_cover_mail_20260730_masked.pdf— Agency for Natural Resources and Energy response transmittal email (body text of the Excel attachment · 2026-07-30)meti_reply_20260713_masked.pdf— Agency for Natural Resources and Energy initial response email (to the 8 public questions · 2026-07-13)meti_reply_20260716_masked.pdf— Agency for Natural Resources and Energy re-response email (to the 6 items for reconfirmation · 2026-07-16)MASKING.md— Masking record (what was redacted)
recommended citation format
Japanese text
益田周防海(2026)「エネ庁、全28問に回答——「検証可能性は担保しない」「比較資料はない」が公式記録になった」株式会社I-S3、2026年7月30日公開、https://www.i-s3.com/jc-star-meti-answers-analysis-20260730.html
English
Masuda, S. (2026). エネ庁、全28問に回答——「検証可能性は担保しない」「比較資料はない」が公式記録になった. I-S3 Co., Ltd. https://www.i-s3.com/jc-star-meti-answers-analysis-20260730.html
BibTeX
@misc{masuda2026jcstar_meti_20260730,
author = {Masuda, Suomi},
title = {エネ庁、全28問に回答——「検証可能性は担保しない」「比較資料はない」が公式記録になった},
year = {2026},
publisher = {I-S3 Co., Ltd.},
url = {https://www.i-s3.com/jc-star-meti-answers-analysis-20260730.html},
note = {Published 2026-07-30. Q\&A dataset (CSV, CC BY 4.0): https://www.i-s3.com/jc-star-answers/}
}
revision history
- October 6, 2026: Added the citation and reuse section, and published the responses as a question-by-question CSV and an original public copy (CC BY 4.0).