Explanatory video (about 10 minutes)
YouTube: Video page / Playlist (record of the public inquiry and verification) / Series overview (Japanese) / English / Chinese
1. Established facts
The facts underlying this article are shown with page numbers from the primary sources. The page numbers are the numbers printed in each document (for Document D, the numbers in the appendix). The document abbreviations correspond to the list of sources.
1-1. New support for ground-mounted installations has already been decided to end
- Fact Business-use solar power generation currently classified as a supported category (ground-mounted, 10 kW or more; therefore including low-voltage systems of 10 kW or more and less than 50 kW) will be excluded from new support under the FIT/FIP system from fiscal 2027 onward. (Document D p.20, Document A p.18)
- Fact The amendments to the subordinate regulations under the Act on Special Measures Concerning Renewable Energy Sources, etc. (ministerial ordinances and public notices) corresponding to this decision have already been promulgated at the end of fiscal 2025 (March 2026) after the public comment procedure, and are scheduled to take effect on April 1, 2027. (Document A p.18)
- Fact The grounds cited for the decision were four points: cost reductions across all scales, winning bids below the auction ceiling price, the formation of projects not relying on FIT/FIP through PPAs, and the situation in which “issues of community coexistence such as the natural environment, safety, and landscape have become apparent, and it has reached a state in which it is being pointed out that so-called ‘negative externalities’ may be occurring.” pointed out (Document D pp.19–20)
- FactThe bidding target is 250 kW or more (from fiscal 2024 onward, FIP 250 kW or more), and the average winning bid price in fiscal 2025 Q3 (the 26th round) is 7.13 yen/kWh. “Winning bids below market price” are the result for this capacity range. (Document E p.12, p.5)
1-2. This review is to select the categories to be retained as exceptions
- FactUnder the policy of prioritizing support for solar PV that is expected to be introduced in a way that promotes coexistence with local communities, the Subcommittee on Main Power Sources for Renewable Energy has selected the categories to be supported other than rooftop installations. (Document A p.2)
- FactThe schedule is to examine specific institutional issues from October 2026 to January 2027, invite public comments on revisions to ministerial ordinances, notices, and guidelines in February to March 2027, and enforce them on April 1, 2027. (Document A p.20, Document B p.5)
- FactThe interviewees are the relevant ministries and agencies (the Ministry of the Environment, the Ministry of Land, Infrastructure, Transport and Tourism, and the Ministry of Agriculture, Forestry and Fisheries), industry groups (JPEA and REASP), and local governments. (Document A p.2, p.19)
1-3. Figures shown by the national government itself
- FactThe assumed system costs for fiscal 2026 are 178,000 yen/kW for ground-mounted installations (10 kW or more and less than 50 kW) and 113,000 yen/kW for ground-mounted installations (50 kW or more). The former is about 1.58 times the latter, or about 60% higher. (Document D p.13, p.16, Appendix p.2)
- FactEven in the periodic reporting data for installations in 2025 (top 36% level), ground-mounted installations (10 kW or more) are 158,000 yen/kW versus 129,000 yen/kW for ground-mounted installations (50 kW or more), so the category that includes smaller-scale systems is higher. (Document D p.13)
- FactProjects of 10 kW or more and less than 50 kW account for about 31% of the total FIT and FIP introduction volume for business-use solar PV, on a capacity basis. (Document D p.10)
- FactThe cumulative number of temporary suspension measures for FIT/FIP grants due to violations of the Forest Act, the Agricultural Land Act, the Land Development Regulation Act, and others is 428 cases (of which 5 were lifted after the violations were resolved). The ratio to the number of certifications and the breakdown by scale are not shown in the document. (Document B p.18)
1-4. Treatment of the current system and existing projects
- FactThe current local utilization requirements for low-voltage FIT projects (10 kW or more and less than 50 kW) are both of the following: 1) at least 30% self-consumption, etc. at the installation site; and 2) autonomous operation in the event of a disaster (being capable of black start) and making the power supply outlet available for general use. (Document E p.41, Document A p.11 note, p.42)
- FactGround-mounted projects that have already received FIT certification are allowed to transition to FIP even from fiscal 2027 onward. (Document D p.99)
- FactWhen replacing or adding solar panels, the price corresponding to the original equipment is maintained, and the “latest procurement price/reference price” is applied to the portion corresponding to the additional output (pro rata calculation). On the other hand, the ground-mounted installation category (10 kW or more) is “support discontinued from fiscal 2027 onward.” (Document D Appendix p.2, p.3 ※, Appendix p.3 note 6)
- FactFor changes to projects outside the bidding scope, the latest procurement price/reference price is applied, and if the latest price is higher, the existing price is retained. (Document D p.98)
1-5. Safety measures and measures for the project entity
- Fact Regarding structures, a system will be established in which a third-party organization with civil engineering and architectural expertise confirms, before construction, compliance with technical standards related to structures for all solar power generation facilities of 10 kW or more (strengthening safety regulations under the Electricity Business Act, with the aim of submitting a bill to the 2026 ordinary Diet session). (Document C p.3)
- Fact On the other hand, as far as can be confirmed, there is no performance requirement in the Electrical Equipment Technical Standards or their interpretation that requires DC wiring that people may touch after shutdown operations to be brought below a certain voltage within a certain time. AIST's guide summarizes that, for Japan, the system voltage after disconnection, triggers, and labels are either "not specified" or limited to the standards for general electrical appliances. (Our article "Even if you stop the PCS, solar power generation does not stop" Section 12. Published on September 26, 2026, updated on October 3 of the same year. Published before the secretariat's draft for prioritizing support (September 30))
- Fact The reason rooftop installations are not subject to the briefing-session certification criteria is that "the scope of possible safety impacts is considered to be limited to the users of the building on that roof." (Document A p.42)
- Fact The policy package sets out "promoting business consolidation into responsible entities that can earn local trust" (long-term stable qualified solar power generation operators) and sharing examples of "taxes outside the law" at the Renewable Energy Local Coexistence Liaison Conference. (Document C p.6, p.4)
- Fact After the decision to exclude them from support (February and March 2026), the Agency for Natural Resources and Energy conducted a "survey on the actual status of the introduction of community-coexisting solar power generation" targeting installers and operators of FIT/FIP facilities introduced over the past six years (response deadline: October 30, 2026). The purpose is said to be basic material for examining "the applicable categories and institutional issues." (Document G)
All of the above is written in materials publicly released by the government itself. Below, we show the inconsistencies among these facts and seek an explanation from the Agency for Natural Resources and Energy.
2. Summary of the national government’s "certain way of thinking" and the secretariat’s draft
Before rebutting, summarize the government's logic accurately in its strongest form.
2-1. A "certain way of thinking" for selecting the category (Materials A p.4)
Types suitable for prioritizing support are said to be those that satisfy all of the following ① to ③ all.
- Future deployment: Based on estimates of deployment potential and the positioning in the Basic Energy Plan, it is a category that is important from the perspective of expanding renewable energy deployment.
- Coexistence with the local community: Satisfies either of the following.
- a: A category that does not involve new land development and does not significantly change the previous land use, so the degree of additional impact on the public interest, such as safety, disaster prevention, landscape, and the environment, is small.
- b: A category in which, through the involvement of local governments or the national government in the project throughout the implementation period, in addition to going through a process of building local understanding such as approval by the mayor or assembly, a certain level of oversight is ensured throughout the implementation period, and if inappropriate project operation occurs, improvements can be urged.
- Characteristics of the FIT/FIP system, etc.: A category whose scope can be clearly defined and confirmed with objective criteria and evidence, and a category in which sales of reverse power flow are assumed.
2-2. Secretariat draft for the 5th meeting (September 30, 2026) (Document A p.5 to 16)
| Category | Type | National summary | 頁 |
|---|---|---|---|
| to be supported | Land owned by the national or local government | Limited to leasehold rights, ground lease rights, or implementation by the national government or local governments themselves (satisfies b). Sold land is excluded because supervision may no longer extend to it. An irrigation pond owned by a neighborhood association does not satisfy b because it does not go through approval by the mayor and the assembly. | p.5 |
| Certified project under the Act on Promotion of Global Warming Countermeasures regional decarbonization promotion project plan | Because there is municipal guidance, advice, and revocation of certification, it satisfies b. Merely being within a promotion area is not sufficient. The same treatment applies to certification of equipment development plans under the Rural Renewable Energy Act. | p.6 | |
| Solar carport | Meets a because it uses the space above the parking lot. Confirmed by inspection certificate, photos, and drawings. | p.9 | |
| Infrastructure spaces (airports, roads, railways, ports, etc.) | On land that has already been developed, a is satisfied because maintaining infrastructure functions is a system premise. | p.10 | |
| Not eligible for support | Supply and funds for local new power companies, municipalities, and local businesses | Contribution to the local economy does not suppress the occurrence of safety, disaster prevention, and other problems, and does not satisfy a. Involvement through contracts or funds does not become a supervision or corrective mechanism, and does not satisfy b either. | p.11 |
| Power supply during disasters | Same as above. "There are issues with adopting benefits brought to the region as an objective criterion, and selection should be based on factors such as the installation location and installation form of the equipment." | p.11 | |
| Within the premises of industrial parks, commercial facilities, etc. | There is no land development involved, but it cannot be ensured that the prior land use will not be significantly changed, so it does not satisfy a. There is no uniform definition, so its scope cannot be clearly drawn. | p.15 | |
| Unused land such as former golf course sites, abandoned farmland, and degraded farmland | There is a "possibility" that logging, topsoil removal, leveling, and new drainage facilities will be carried out, so it does not satisfy a. There is no public evidence and the extent cannot be defined. | p.16 | |
| Postponement | Agrivoltaics | Prioritize enforcement of the Ministry of Agriculture, Forestry and Fisheries system revision, and continue consideration from the next fiscal year onward. | p.12 |
As a result of this整理, ground-mounted installations on privately owned land are excluded from support regardless of who owns the land, unless they are included in an approved plan, regardless of design details or violation history. Does the government intend this outcome? If not, how will it prevent it? This is the starting point of this article's question.
3. Issue — The evaluation criteria and the selection method do not match
Subject: The line for "regional coexistence" should be drawn not by the project entity, the landowner, or the formal category on paper, but by the performance of the equipment and design. Existing projects that comply with the relevant laws and regulations must not later be subjected to disadvantages.
Expected counterargument From the government side, one can expect the argument that future subsidies are not a right of the business operator, and that how to define the scope of new support is a matter of policy discretion. Our company does not dispute that premise itself. What we dispute is that the exercise of discretion lacks consistency with the evaluation criteria indicated by the government itself (Document A, p.4) and lacks reasonable grounds. The points are set out below in seven parts.
3-1. Supply to the grid itself is a contribution to the region, which is the purpose of the law
Article 1 of the Act on Special Measures Concerning Procurement of Electricity from Renewable Energy Sources by Electricity Utilities states that the purpose of the law is to contribute to "regional revitalization and other sound development of the national economy" by promoting the supply of renewable energy electricity (text of the article). Ground-mounted power plants that supply electricity to the grid have been installed in line with this purpose and have received certification under the law.
The Secretariat's draft does not require rooftop installations to make any regional contribution beyond grid supply. Rooftop installations are described as "a representative example of a type in which regional coexistence has been achieved" (Document A, p.2), and the reason given is that their additional impact is small, not that they provide additional contributions to the region (Document A, p.39). By contrast, ground-mounted installations are required to have elements of "contribution or supervision" such as public land, certified plans, and infrastructure space. There is no difference between rooftop and ground-mounted systems in the contribution of supplying power to the grid. If the difference lies in the magnitude of impact, then what should be assessed is the impact itself, such as whether land development was involved, the location, the design, and any history of violations, not the landowner. This point is raised in Question 5.
3-2. The evaluation axis is "risk and supervision," yet the selection is being made based on "owner and documents"
Item ②a on p.4 of Document A requires that the degree of additional impact on the public interest be small, and item ②b requires that supervision be secured and that improvements can be urged if inappropriate business operations occur. In other words, the government's evaluation criteria are, in substance, the magnitude of risk and the corrective measures available when that risk materializes.
However, the actual application is being made based on whether the land is public land, whether it is included in a certified plan, and whether it is land for infrastructure use—namely, the land owner and the documentary category. Whether the design involves no land development, whether there is embankment, whether drainage is changed, or whether there has been a past violation of laws and regulations is not used in determining any category. The reason unused land and abandoned farmland were excluded was that tree felling and land clearing “may be carried out” (Document A p.16), not that they will be carried out.
Under criterion b, a local individual or small business that carries out a project on its own land, fully complies with all relevant laws and regulations, holds briefing sessions, and sets aside funds for decommissioning can, structurally, never become a "coexistence type". That is because there is no route for approval by the mayor or the assembly in the case of a private project on privately owned land. Does the government intend this outcome? If not, how will it prevent it (Question 6)?
3-3. Land with risks is most suitable for solar power depending on the design
The risks of a site must be considered in two categories. Disaster risk is the risk that the land will suffer damage from flooding, landslides, strong winds, and so on, while induced risk is the risk that installation work or equipment will cause damage to the surrounding area. What item ②a on p.4 of Document A addresses is the latter, namely "additional impact".
If the design does not involve land development, embankment, tree felling, or changes to drainage, the induced risk does not increase. In addition, land with only a high disaster risk, such as flood-prone areas or low-lying land unsuitable for housing, is a reasonable use for solar power generation that is unmanned, has no permanent human presence, and confines damage to the equipment owner. Using land on which housing or occupied facilities cannot be built for power generation without additional impact does not run counter to the purpose of ②a.
The risk on the DC side during flooding can be managed through equipment installation height and shutdown functions. Using the fire at a junction box after flooding in Narita City in September 2026 as a case study, our company organized the relationship between the lower edge height of the junction box (about 0.5 to 1.0 m above ground in a centralized system) and flood depth, the results of a submersion test showing that the insulation resistance of a submerged junction box does not recover even after washing and drying, and the fact that in locations where the assumed flood depth exceeds 3 m, equipment height alone cannot provide escape and the ability to cut off DC remotely becomes central to the design (Why the Narita City Otake junction box fire shows the need to replace central inverters). Disaster risk at the site is a variable that can be managed through design documents and equipment specifications, and it is not a reason to exclude such sites uniformly (Question 8).
3-4. Electrical safety should be ensured by equipment performance standards, not by business operator discipline
As for the structure of the policy package, it introduces an equipment-based regulation for “all facilities of 10 kW or more must be confirmed by a third-party organization to comply with technical standards” (Document C p.3). This is a method that ensures safety based on whether the equipment meets the standards, not on who the operator is, and our company supports this direction.
However, the same approach is not taken for electrical safety, namely electric shock and fire spread during fire or flooding. Even if the inverter is stopped, several hundred volts remain on the DC wiring as long as there is sunlight. There is no performance requirement in Japan's technical standards for electrical installations and their interpretation that requires the DC voltage to be reduced below a certain value within a certain time after shutdown (Our article, Sections 12 and 14). What the government has prepared for electrical safety in this state is an obligation to hold briefing sessions and a business operator discipline of temporary suspension of subsidies in the event of violations (Document A, pp.28 and 38).
It would reduce risk more directly than selecting by entity if a performance standard equivalent to rapid shutdown, namely a requirement that after shutdown the voltage must fall below a specified level within a specified number of seconds, were made mandatory regardless of installation form or installing entity. Moreover, rooftop installations, which are treated as the "representative example" for prioritizing support, are precisely where firefighters and residents are most likely to approach live DC conductors during a building fire. For rooftop installations, the government has organized the matter by stating that "the scope of safety impacts that may arise is limited to the users of the building on which the rooftop is installed" (Document A, p.42), but the very fact that impacts can reach building users is the reason a performance standard is needed. It is inconsistent to include equipment standards for structure but not for electrical safety (Question 9).
3-5. Resilience can be evaluated objectively
The secretariat draft excluded power supply during disasters on the grounds that “there are challenges in adopting the benefits brought to the local area as an objective criterion” (Document A p.11). However, a note on the same page of the same document states that the current low-voltage FIT already operates with “the ability to be utilized during disasters” as a local utilization requirement. Its substance is “on the premise that black start is possible during a disaster, it has a power supply outlet and that the power supply outlet can be used during a disaster” (Document A p.42, Document E p.41), which is an objective criterion that can be confirmed by the functions of the equipment. The government has, in effect, evaluated an objective criterion that it itself operates as presenting “challenges in adopting it as an objective criterion.”
The supply capability in a disaster can be confirmed from the specifications, type certification, and test reports for the following items.
- Whether grid-forming functionality (operating as a voltage source and independently forming frequency and voltage) is present, and its capacity
- Whether black start (restart without an external power source) is possible
- Output capacity during independent operation (kW) and the range of circuits that can be supplied
- Battery storage capacity (kWh) and duration during nighttime and no-sunlight periods
- Response to planned islanded operation (operation in which, within a range agreed in advance with the general transmission and distribution utility, the area is separated and supplied during a grid outage)
Establishing a support category for a hybrid design that "supplies power to the grid under normal conditions and supplies power autonomously to the local area in emergencies," and using the above items as certification criteria, satisfies item ③ on p.4 of Document A, namely that the scope can be defined by objective criteria and evidence, and that reverse power flow exists. At the same time, we ask that the grid interconnection rules be developed to include a system for planned island operation. In another article, our company has argued that being connected over a wide area is different from being centrally controlled over a wide area, and that a power source that measures physical quantities on site and operates autonomously does not reduce grid reliability (Wide-area connection does not require wide-area control, What is true resilience in the era of distributed power sources?, Load-equivalent autonomous resilience architecture (LEAA)). We would like the basis for saying that disaster-time supply cannot be "objectively evaluated" to be shown (Question 7).
3-6. The judgment that it has become self-sustaining does not apply to low-voltage systems
The grounds for excluding support are cost reductions, winning bids below the auction ceiling, and the emergence of PPA projects (Document D pp.19–20). However, the auction applies to projects of 250 kW or more (Document E p.12), and the decline in winning prices is the result of competition among projects of 250 kW or more. Project formation through PPA is also occurring in the scale range where customers contract directly.
According to the government's own assumptions, system costs in fiscal 2026 will be 178,000 yen/kW for low-voltage systems (10 kW or more but less than 50 kW) and 113,000 yen/kW for 50 kW or more, meaning low-voltage systems are about 60% more expensive (Document D, pp.13 and 16). Even in the latest periodic reporting data, the top 36% level for 10 kW or more, at 158,000 yen/kW, exceeds the 129,000 yen/kW for 50 kW or more (Document D, p.13). The government writes that cost reductions have been achieved "for all scales," but achieving a reduction and reaching a level at which new investment proceeds even without FIT/FIP, which is the "self-sustaining" level assumed by the system in Document D, p.7, are different matters. Is there an analysis that judged self-sustaining viability for low-voltage systems alone, or is there not (Question 4)?
3-7. Retroactive disadvantages imposed on existing lawful projects should be explicitly prohibited
This system change is said to define the scope of new certifications, but parts that affect existing certified projects are already visible in the materials.
- For panel replacement and expansion, the "latest procurement price/benchmark price" applies to the additional output, but for ground-mounted installations, support is stopped from fiscal 2027 onward (Appendix p.3, note 6). There may be no price that applies to the increased output. This conflicts with the policy of encouraging repowering under the long-term stable qualified solar PV operator system (Document C p.6) (Question 10).
- Procurement conditions, the order of output control, the requirements for change certification, the conditions for FIP transition, and the handling of subsidies can all be changed by ministerial ordinances, public notices, and guidelines. Nowhere in the current materials is there any assurance that, merely because a category does not apply, these will not be changed in a way that is unfavorable to existing projects (Question 11).
- The "promotion of business consolidation into responsible entities" and the sharing of examples of "taxes outside the statutory framework" (Document C p.6, p.4) can be read as measures aimed at small businesses that are already operating. It should be made clear whether or not the goal is the exit of small businesses (Question 12).
Changing conditions after the fact, on the basis of a category, for businesses that complied with the law, obtained certification, and invested on the premise of a 20-year procurement period, raises issues under Article 29 of the Constitution regarding property rights, protection of legitimate expectations, and legal stability (Section 6). Our company seeks a commitment on this point.
4. Comparison between the national secretariat’s draft and our counterproposal
The government's secretariat proposal and the alternative proposal based on the performance criteria presented in this article are compared side by side across the same five axes. Each item in the alternative proposal is designed to satisfy ① to ③ in Document A p.4. If it is said not to satisfy them, Question 15 asks which item fails to meet which requirement.
| 軸 | National secretariat draft (Materials A pp. 5–16) | Our alternative proposal |
|---|---|---|
| Decision criteria | Land owner (national government/local government), administrative involvement (certified plan), documentary classification (carport/infrastructure space). | Performance of equipment and design. ① Design that does not increase induced risks, ② performance of electrical safety, ③ self-supply capability. The business entity and the landowner are not relevant. |
| Land | Public land (leasehold rights, superficies), certified projects in promotion areas, carports, infrastructure spaces. Ground-mounted installations on privately owned land are excluded regardless of design or violation history. Distinguish disaster risk from induced risk. | Confirm in the design documents that there is no land development, embankment, tree felling, or drainage change. Land with only a high disaster risk (such as flood hazard areas) is eligible on the condition of equipment height and remote shutdown. Projects involving construction that increases induced risk are excluded. |
| Safety | Structure: third-party technical standard conformity verification (equipment standards). Electrical safety relies on business operator discipline through briefing sessions and temporary suspension of subsidies. No requirement for DC voltage after suspension. | In addition to structure, electrical safety should also be included in the equipment standards. Make the performance standard of ○V or less within ○ seconds after shutdown mandatory for all installation forms, including rooftop installations. The method is not specified. Record the measured voltage after shutdown at handover. |
| Regional contribution | Grid supply is not evaluated as a contribution. Local supply, funds, and disaster-time supply are excluded as "there are challenges in adopting them as objective criteria." | Evaluate grid supply as a contribution under Article 1 of the law. For disaster-time supply, evaluate grid-forming, black start, autonomous operation capacity, battery storage capacity, and support for planned islanded operation by specification, and add hybrid designs to the support categories. |
| Verification method | Certificate of registered matters, public property ledger, contract for title to use, certification document, inspection certificate under the Building Standards Act, photos and drawings. | Design documents (presence or absence of land development and drainage plans), equipment type certification and test reports (voltage after shutdown, GFM, black start, autonomous operation capacity), and actual measurement records at handover and during periodic inspections. All are documents that can be verified by a third party. |
The counterproposal applies to equipment performance, rather than land type, the method already used by the national government for rooftop installations, namely “defining the scope by unique certification criteria and submitted documents” (Document A pp.40 and 42). Even if the number of documents used for confirmation increases, the requirement in ③ that it be confirmable by “objective criteria and evidence” is not impaired.
5. Public questions (A–E, 17 items)
The following questions are addressed to the New Energy Division, Energy Efficiency and New Energy Department, Agency for Natural Resources and Energy. Each item is framed so it can be answered with yes/no, a number, or whether a record exists. Sent on October 13, 2026. The response deadline is November 12, 2026, 30 days after submission, and the full text of any response, non-response, or refusal to respond will be published in this article together with the date. Any item not answered by the deadline will be recorded as "No response".
A. Basis
Question 1 Negative externality data by scale
Please provide data showing the incidence of negative externalities (accidents, violations of related laws and regulations, complaints) by scale: low-voltage (10 kW or more and less than 50 kW), high-voltage, and extra-high voltage.
- Please show the basis for making all projects from 10 kW or more but less than 50 kW ineligible, even though the name of the countermeasure package is "Countermeasure Package for Large-Scale Solar Power Generation Projects (Mega Solar)."
- Whether there is a record of considering distinguishing the scope outside the support target by scale, and if so, please indicate its contents.
Basis: Document C title, Document D pp.19–20 (the basis is said to be "situations where points are raised," and no data by scale are shown).
Question 2 The denominator for 428 cases
What percentage of FIT/FIP certified projects does the cumulative 428 cases of temporary suspension of subsidies due to violations of relevant laws and regulations represent? At that level, please show the rationality of excluding all low-voltage ground-mounted projects. In addition, please show the breakdown of the 428 cases by scale (low-voltage, high-voltage, special high-voltage).
Basis: Document B p.18 (cumulative total of 428 cases, of which 5 were rescinded. No description of the denominator or breakdown by scale).
Question 3 The purpose of the actual-condition survey to be conducted after the decision
Please indicate the purpose of conducting the "questionnaire survey on the actual status of introduction of community-coexistence solar power generation" after the decision to exclude it from support (the February 2026 summary of opinions and the March 2026 ministerial ordinance and notice promulgation).
- Please indicate whether the survey results may lead to a review of the decision to exclude ground-mounted installations uniformly.
- Will aggregated results including incidence rates by type and scale be made public? If so, please indicate the timing and format.
Basis: Document G (survey purpose, subject, deadline), Document A p.18, Document D p.20.
Question 4 Analysis of self-sufficiency for low-voltage standalone systems
The assumed system cost for low-voltage systems (10 kW or more but less than 50 kW) is 178,000 yen/kW, about 60% higher than the 113,000 yen/kW for 50 kW or more. Even so, please indicate whether there is any analysis of cost and profitability for low-voltage systems alone that concluded that even including low-voltage systems, the level had reached one at which “new power source investment progresses even without the FIT/FIP system.” Please also explain why winning bids below the auction ceiling (250 kW or more) and the formation of PPA projects were used as grounds for low-voltage self-sufficiency.
Basis: Material D p.7 (definition of self-sufficiency), p.13, p.16, Appendix p.2 (assumed values), p.19–20 (reasons for judgment), Material E p.12 (bidding target 250 kW or more).
B. Consistency of standards
Question 5 Isn't grid supply a contribution to the local community?
Article 1 of the Act on Special Measures Concerning Procurement of Electricity from Renewable Energy Sources states that its purpose is to contribute to "regional revitalization and other sound development of the national economy" through the promotion of supply of renewable energy electricity. Please show the reason for not evaluating power supply to the grid itself as a contribution to the region, and the legal basis for that.
- Please show the basis for requiring regional contributions other than grid supply for rooftop installations, and requiring them only for ground-mounted installations.
Basis: Act on Special Measures Concerning Procurement of Electricity from Renewable Energy Sources by Electricity Utilities Article 1, Document A p.2, p.39, p.42.
Question 6 Local individuals and small and medium-sized enterprises cannot be "coexistence-type"
Under criterion b, lawful projects carried out by local individuals and small and medium-sized enterprises on their own land structurally cannot become "coexistence-type" because there is no route through approval by the mayor or the assembly. Is this the intended consequence? If not intended, please show how this consequence will be prevented.
Basis: Document A p.4 (criterion b), p.5 (exclusion of sold land, note on irrigation ponds), p.15–16 (exclusion of privately owned land types).
Question 7 The basis for deeming the objective criteria it operates by itself to have "issues"
The current local utilization requirements for low-voltage FIT—namely, that black start in a disaster must be possible and that the outlet for power supply must be usable in a disaster—are already being operated as objective criteria that can be confirmed by the functions of the equipment. Even so, please show the basis for stating that using power supply in a disaster as an “objective criterion” presents challenges.
- Please show the reason for not considering classification based on specifications such as grid-forming function, black start, autonomous operation capacity, battery storage capacity, and support for planned islanded operation. If there is a record of such consideration, please show it.
Basis: Document A p.11 (main text and notes), p.42, Document E p.41.
Question 8 Rationality of excluding a design with no induced risk based solely on location
For projects for which the design documents can confirm that there is no land development, embankment, tree felling, or drainage change, please show the rationality of excluding them solely because of the disaster risk of the site. Is the "additional impact on the public interest" addressed by criterion a not an induced risk that can be confirmed by design?
Basis: Document A p.4 (criterion a), p.16 (exclusion on the grounds that it "may be carried out").
C. Safety
Question 9 What is effective for electrical safety: selecting the subject, or performance standards for equipment?
Regarding electrical safety (electric shock and fire spread during fire/flooding), please indicate which of the following two is evaluated as more effective in reducing risk.
- Selection by installation entity or type
- Mandatory equipment performance standards that reduce DC voltage to a specified value or below within a certain time after shutdown (equivalent to rapid shutdown)
While introducing third-party technical standard conformity verification for structures, please also explain why the performance standards for electrical safety are not being considered, including rooftop installations.
Basis: Material C p.3, Material A p.28, p.38, p.42, and our article "Even if the PCS is stopped, solar power generation does not stop" Sections 12 and 14.
D. Existing lawful business operations
Question 10 Price applied to the additional capacity
For fiscal 2027 and later, please indicate the procurement price/base price that will apply to the increased output when existing ground-mounted facilities are expanded or panels are replaced.
- If there is no applicable price, please explain why this does not conflict with the long-term stable qualified solar power operator system, which encourages appropriate project implementation including maintenance and repowering.
Basis: Document D Appendix p.2 and p.3 (※), Appendix p.3 Note 6, Document C p.6.
Question 11 Commitment not to make retroactive disadvantageous changes
For existing certified projects that comply with relevant laws and regulations, please commit that, on the basis of their applicability to the support-prioritization categories, the following matters will not be changed retroactively to their disadvantage. If there are matters for which you cannot commit, please show those matters and the reasons.
- Procurement conditions (procurement price, benchmark price, procurement period, grant period)
- Order of output control
- Requirements for change certification
- Conditions for FIP transition
- Treatment of subsidies
Basis: Document D p.98 (price operation for change certification), p.99 (transition to FIP), Document A p.41 (institutional issues to be considered going forward).
Question 12 Business consolidation and non-statutory taxes
Does "promoting business consolidation to responsible entities that can earn local trust" mean that the policy objective is the exit of small-scale operators?
- Does the government take the position of permitting or recommending local government taxes outside the statutory tax system on facilities that are operating lawfully? Please indicate the purpose of sharing examples of such taxes at the Renewable Energy Regional Coexistence Liaison Conference.
Basis: Materials C pp. 6, 4.
E. Procedures and responsibility
Question 13 Channels for hearing the opinions of low-voltage individual and small and medium-sized businesses
Please show through which channels the opinions of low-voltage individual and small and medium-sized business operators were heard in the subcommittee hearings (relevant ministries and agencies, JPEA, REASP, local governments). If they were not heard, please state that.
Basis: Materials A pp. 2, 19.
Question 14 Record of the decision and the decision-making body
For each judgment related to Questions 1, 6, and 7 (blanket exclusion of low-voltage, adoption of criterion b, exclusion of disaster-time supply), please indicate the meeting materials and examination records that served as the basis, and the decision-maker (meeting body or approver).
Basis: Materials D p.20, Materials A p.4, p.11.
Question 15 Reasons for not adopting the alternative proposal
If the counterproposal based on the performance criteria shown in Section 4 of this article (① induced-risk criteria, ② electrical safety performance criteria, ③ classification by autonomous supply capability) is not adopted, please show, for each item in the counterproposal, which of the national "certain way of thinking" items ① to ③ is not satisfied.
Basis: Materials A p.4, p.40, p.42.
Question 16 Publication of the results of consideration in the public comment process
Please show whether, in the public comment procedure scheduled for February to March 2027, if opinions with the same intent as this question are submitted, the "results of consideration of the submitted opinions and the reasons therefor" under Article 43, paragraph 1, item 4 of the Administrative Procedure Act are planned to be published for each item.
Basis: Materials A p.20, Administrative Procedure Act Articles 42 and 43.
Question 17 Mechanism for post-implementation verification
Please indicate whether there are plans to establish a mechanism for ex post verification of the appropriateness of the judgment if this institutional change causes disadvantages to existing lawful operators (verification timing, verifying body, indicators). Please also indicate at what time and in what forum the review required by Article 38, paragraph 2 of the Administrative Procedure Act—taking into account “the status of implementation of the provisions, changes in social and economic conditions, etc.”—will be conducted.
Basis: Article 38, paragraph 2 of the Administrative Procedure Act.
6. Legal framework and future response
The provisions of the laws and regulations related to this matter are quoted as confirmed in the e-Gov Law Search. Rather than concluding from the provisions themselves, they are presented as a framework for asking the government to show reasonable grounds.
6-1. Renewable Energy Special Measures Act Article 1 — Consistency with the purpose of the Act
The law positions the "promotion of supply" of renewable energy electricity as the means, and "regional revitalization" as its consequence. An interpretation that excludes grid supply from regional contribution requires an explanation of consistency with the purpose provision of the law (Question 5).
6-2. Constitution Article 29, protection of trust, legal stability — retroactive disadvantages imposed on existing certified projects
2 The content of property rights shall be determined by law so as to conform to the public welfare. Constitution of Japan Article 29, Paragraphs 1 and 2 ― e-Gov Law Search
Operators who received FIT certification and invested on the premise of a 20-year procurement period have a legitimate expectation that the conditions at the time of certification will be maintained. If amendments to ministerial ordinances, public notices, or guidelines make the conditions for existing projects less favorable on the basis of whether they fall within a category, the government is asked to explain whether this falls within the scope of the delegation of “law” that defines the content of property rights, and whether it can be justified from the perspective of protection of legitimate expectations and legal stability (Questions 10 and 11).
6-3. Constitution Article 14, principle of proportionality — rooftop and ground-mounted systems, additional requirements imposed on lawful projects
Policy discretion in defining the scope of support is broad. However, with respect to distinguishing equipment that performs the same grid supply by the land owner rather than by equipment performance or actual impact, and imposing requirements that go beyond legal compliance—such as public ownership of the land or inclusion in a certified plan—on projects that comply with all relevant laws and regulations, the burden is on the government to show that there is a rational connection between the purpose of the distinction and the means. This article does not conclude that this is unconstitutional. It remains a question asking for rational grounds (Questions 5, 6, and 8).
6-4. Administrative Procedure Act Chapter 6 — Public comment procedure and publication of the consideration results
Article 42 When an administrative agency that establishes orders, etc. conducts a public comment procedure and establishes orders, etc., it must sufficiently consider the opinions on the draft orders, etc. submitted to that agency during the opinion submission period (hereinafter referred to as "submitted opinions").
Article 43 When an ordinance-making body has established ordinances, etc. through the public comment procedure, it shall, at the same time as the promulgation of the relevant ordinances, etc. (omitted), publicly announce the following matters. (omitted)
4. Results of considering the submitted opinions (including differences between the draft orders, etc. for which the public comment procedure was implemented, and the orders, etc. as determined) and the reasons therefor Administrative Procedure Act (Act No. 88 of 1993), Article 39, Paragraph 1, Article 42, Article 43, Paragraph 1, Item 4 — e-Gov Law Search
Our company will submit the questions and counterproposal in this article as comments in the public comment procedure for the amendments to ministerial ordinances, public notices, and guidelines scheduled for February to March 2027, and will request item-by-item publication of the consideration results and reasons under Article 43, paragraph 1, item 4 (Question 16). In addition, we ask at what time and in what forum the review required by Article 38, paragraph 2 of the same Act—taking into account the “status of implementation of the provisions, changes in social and economic conditions, etc.” after enactment—will be conducted (Question 17).
6-5. Information Disclosure Act — Request for disclosure of underlying data
In parallel with this public question, based on Article 3 of the same Act, a request will be made for disclosure of the following administrative documents.
- Documents showing the number of violations of relevant laws and regulations, accidents, and complaints by scale (low voltage, high voltage, extra-high voltage), and the breakdown by scale of the 428 cases of temporary suspension of subsidies
- Specifications, survey form, aggregation design document, and aggregated results of the "Questionnaire Survey on the Actual Status of Introduction of Community-Coexisting Solar Power Generation"
- Records of considering classifying the scope outside support for business-use solar (ground-mounted) by scale, and cost-profitability analysis for low-voltage standalone systems
- Record of deliberations that led to the conclusion that using power supply during disasters as an objective criterion poses challenges
6-6. Future response and declaration of continued verification
- Posting the responses: For all of the responses, non-responses, and refusals to respond, the full text will be posted in this article together with the date.
- Analysis article: If a response is received, an analysis article comparing each item with primary sources will be published.
- Disclosure request: A disclosure request will be filed for the documents in 6-5 above, and the disclosed documents will be published with only the names and contact details of the administrative side's individuals redacted.
- Public comment: In the public comment procedure in February to March 2027, the questions and counterproposal in this article will be submitted, and the notice of the consideration results will be followed.
- Ongoing verification: Based on the questions and answers in this article, we will continuously verify what results the judgment in this matter has brought to existing businesses, the region, and the burden on the public. Even after enforcement, we will track the number of certifications, installed capacity, number of violations, output control, and trends in procurement prices from published materials, and add the verification results to this article.
7. Disclosure of conflicts of interest
- I-S3 Co., Ltd. is a party engaged in the construction and maintenance of solar power generation equipment (including SolarEdge and other equipment) and the operation of low-voltage solar power plants. This change in the system will have a direct impact on our business and on customer equipment that we maintain.
- The electrical safety standard equivalent to rapid shutdown requested in this article is proposed not as a specific method or a product from a specific manufacturer, but as a performance standard of "within ○ seconds after shutdown, at or below ○ V." Which method is used to satisfy it should be chosen by the designer and the installer.
- Our article on DC safety, published on September 26, 2026, was released before the secretariat draft on prioritizing support, shown on September 30 of the same year.
- This article does not include information on individual power plants, business partners, or customers.
8. List of sources
Page numbers are the numbers printed on each document. In Document D, the "Appendix" is numbered separately from the main text.
- Material A: Agency for Natural Resources and Energy, "About prioritizing support under the FIT/FIP system for business-use solar power generation," 5th meeting of the Subcommittee on Renewable Energy as a Main Power Source of the Advisory Committee for Natural Resources and Energy (September 30, 2026), Material 1. PDF
- Material B: Same, 3rd meeting (July 28, 2026), Material 2. PDF
- Material C: Council of Ministers concerned with the Large-Scale Solar Power Generation Project, "Countermeasure Package for Large-Scale Solar Power Generation Projects (Mega Solar)" (decided on December 23, 2025). PDF
- Material D: Procurement Price Calculation Committee, "Opinion on Procurement Prices, etc. from Fiscal Year 2026 Onward" (February 5, 2026). PDF
- Document E: Agency for Natural Resources and Energy, "About bidding system and local utilization requirements," Procurement Price Calculation Committee (January 2026), Document 1. PDF
- Document F: Laws and regulations (e-Gov Law Search). Act on Special Measures Concerning the Promotion of the Use of Electricity from Renewable Energy Sources / Constitution of Japan / Administrative Procedure Act / Act on Access to Information Held by Administrative Organs
- Document G: Agency for Natural Resources and Energy, "Questionnaire Survey on the Introduction Status of Community-Based Solar Power Generation" (response deadline: October 30, 2026). Public page
Confirmation of the contact point: the contact listed on the public page of the Subcommittee on Making Renewable Energy a Main Power Source is “Agency for Natural Resources and Energy, Energy Conservation and New Energy Department, New Energy Division, Tel. 03-3501-1511 (ext. 4551–4556)” (confirmed on October 13, 2026).