What you can understand in 30 seconds
- Q8: "Having obtained the conformity label" does not mean that it is "safely installed and operated" (stated by IPA). The effect of the label does not change depending on the installation location
- Design philosophy: ★1 assumes that equipment with an attack surface receives direct communications from outside and is designed to meet the conformity requirements — direct exposure is not abnormal, but part of the expected normal state
- Q11: Even exceptions obtained at the vendor's discretion are said to have "no distinguishing indication" — all exception routes are invisible and uniform
- Q12: The number and percentage of exceptions obtained are "not disclosed. There are also no plans to disclose them"
- Q13: There is "no" public document that describes the viewpoints and decision criteria for supply chain inquiries
- Q10 (correction): Model number verification is possible because the product names and model numbers are listed in the attached configuration diagram — the review again assumes that one must "read the configuration diagram"
- Accordingly, the proposition that "the 2027 grid-connection review will be a review that confirms nothing about installation safety" can be demonstrated to completion using only IPA's exact wording, and nothing else
Explanatory video — Japanese, English, and Chinese
The label does not indicate “safe installation or operation,” assumes direct exposure, and exception statistics are not disclosed — the facts confirmed in the third response and the summary of the overall themes are explained in a video in Japanese, English, and Simplified Chinese.
| Language | Title | On-site viewing | YouTube |
|---|---|---|---|
| Japanese | The label does not indicate “safe installation” — IPA Third Response and the illusion of 2027 grid security | Reproduction | Watch |
| English | 2027 Grid Mandate Autopsy — Label Does NOT Mean "Safely Installed" | Reproduction | Watch |
| Simplified Chinese | Labels ≠ Safe Installation — IPA Third Response and the 2027 Grid Connection Mandatory Requirements Explained | Reproduction | Watch |
There is also a short version that compresses the key points into 60 seconds: Japanese / English / Simplified Chinese.
Sequel — The logical breakdown of mandatory implementation (Japanese/English/Chinese): Japanese / English / Simplified Chinese (Shorts: JP/EN/CN).
Further sequel — It is not about scale. It is about the reach structure. (Japanese/English/Chinese): Japanese / English / Simplified Chinese (Shorts: JP/EN/CN) | Special feature article.
Latest work — Dissecting METI’s 28 answers (July 30, 2026, Japanese, English, Chinese): Japanese / English / Simplified Chinese|Full responses and analysis.
Additional inquiries to the Agency for Natural Resources and Energy (Q19 to Q28) are here. The entire series is compiled in the playlist.
1. What was confirmed in the third response
The response to the facts re-inquiry definitively confirmed the questions raised in the previous article. All of them are organizational responses from the IPA Security Center.
1-1. The label does not indicate installation safety (Q8)
"Having obtained the conformity label" does not mean that it is "safely installed and operated," but rather indicates that "the equipment within the scope of the label has conformity requirements required by ★1, such as access control from external networks and vulnerability response" — IPA exact wording.
Analysis The point I read in Chapter 7 of the previous draft, that “the installation configuration does not exist in the label variables,” has now been officially confirmed, not merely inferred. Since the purpose of the grid interconnection requirements is “the safety of installed equipment,” a design that places at its entry a label that does not indicate installation safety is, at the definitional level, a confirmed mismatch between purpose and means.
1-2. All exception routes are invisible (Q11)
Fact Even for the exception in Supplementary Guidance 1-6 (acquisition based on vendor judgment), “there is no indication that it is an exception application.” Together with Q3 in the previous draft (the 1-4 exception), all exception routes are invisible on the list and label.
1-3. Exception statistics are not disclosed and no plans to do so (Q12)
Fact The number and proportion of acquisitions through exceptional applications are “not disclosed. There are also no plans to disclose them.” Those subject to regulation cannot verify what share of the interconnection entry is subject to undisclosed individual judgments.
1-4. There is no baseline document for supply chain inquiries (Q13)
Fact Regarding the supply chain risk inquiry to government-related organizations specified in the footnote to Section 1.3 of the conformity criteria, there is “no” public document that states the viewpoints or judgment criteria. The structure in which the criteria are undisclosed despite being a issuance condition was confirmed in the initial response.
1-5. Correction of wording (fairness)
Correction Regarding my expression that “the conformity label confirms the attributes of the product,” IPA said that this is “incorrect” and defined it as a marker that indicates conformity with the prescribed security requirements and conformity requirements for equipment within the scope of the label. At the same time, it explicitly stated that it “does not confirm or guarantee complete safety” and is a “manufacturer’s self-declaration of conformity.” The conclusion does not change—rather, it is reinforced by the direct answer that it does not indicate that the equipment is installed and operated safely. The following descriptions will follow this IPA definition.
Fact IPA also explicitly stated that it has post-market surveillance and the authority to revoke labels. We record the existence of post-market control fairly. The activation criteria and track record have not been disclosed.
2. Design philosophy of "direct exposure assumed" — an unexpected harvest
Fact IPA explained as follows.
Analysis As a product label, it is a consistent concept: requiring products that can withstand at least the minimum wherever they are placed. But when repurposed for grid interconnection, a decisive consequence arises.
- JC-STAR side: Requires product hygiene on the assumption of a world without boundaries (direct exposure = normal operation within expectations)
- Scope of the Agency for Natural Resources and Energy’s requirements: “Equipment via gateways, etc. is excluded” — a definition premised on the effectiveness of boundary defense
The premises of the two systems are exact opposites (the “blank space 2” in the analysis of the first response). Moreover, the threat model of the labeled requirements does not treat an exposed configuration as abnormal; rather, it is designed on the assumption that it will be exposed. Since the purpose of the interconnection requirements is the safe connection of equipment, a design that relies only on product requirements that treat exposure as normal to ensure installation safety has, at the definitional level, a confirmed mismatch between purpose and means.
3. IPA Third Response Original Text
Fact The following are the key points of the response received on July 26, 2026 (personal names and personal addresses are omitted; treated as an organizational response). The full text of the question is published in Chapter 8 of the previous draft.
Analysis All questions were answered in less than a day after the submission. For Q8, they went beyond a multiple-choice response and explained the design philosophy, and also pointed out the inaccuracy in our wording. Through three rounds of inquiry, IPA’s responses have been consistently prompt and sincere. The target of criticism is not IPA, but the decision to repurpose this kind of label as an interconnection entry requirement.
4. Correction — the model number can be confirmed in the configuration diagram. Its meaning
Correction I update the description in Chapter 5, fault point 1 of the previous draft, which stated that there is no public mechanism for a third party to verify the correspondence. Based on the Q10 response, the attached configuration diagram lists the product names and model numbers of each component device, so it is possible to confirm whether they are the target devices there. There is no machine-readable correspondence table, but it can be confirmed by opening the configuration diagram PDF for each product.
Analysis Together with Q4, which states that the evaluation scope is identified in the configuration diagram, the system has twice assumed that reviewers will read the configuration diagram. The anticipated rebuttal from the current proposal side, that “checking the configuration diagram is not part of review practice,” no longer holds. If the configuration diagram can be read, the alternative proposal is feasible; if it cannot be read, then the current proposal’s label check also does not function. Either way, the basis for claiming that the current proposal is superior to the alternative disappears (comparison across 10 criteria).
5. Theme summary — the overall picture confirmed through three inquiries
Analysis The verification that began with a public question to the Ministry of Economy, Trade and Industry, and then proceeded through written inquiries to the Agency for Natural Resources and Energy and IPA, has established the following overall picture solely from the verbatim statements of the label operation body itself.
| stage | confirmed facts (primary source) | record |
|---|---|---|
| First answer | Boundary defense is not considered / ★1 is not power-specific / evaluation is for the PCS alone | Analysis of the first response |
| Second answer | No view on legal citations / no document stating it is not a substitute / no distinction for exception acquisition / exceptions are non-public individual judgments / the purpose of exceptions is "prevention of business disadvantage" | Analysis of the second response |
| careful reading of public documents | There may be an identification model number for JC-STAR / non-public SC inquiry before issuance (compliance criteria footnote) | Second answer analysis Chapter 4 |
| Third answer (this draft) | The label does not indicate installation safety / ★1 assumes direct exposure / all exceptions are invisible / exception statistics are not disclosed and not planned / no public document for SC inquiry criteria | this paper |
Core proposition (final form): When the 2027 interconnection review confirms the “use of JC-STAR★1 certified products,” that confirmation will be carried out——while double-assuming the reading of the configuration diagram, and without seeing the type of exceptions, statistics, or criteria——by checking only the presence or absence of a label that says nothing about installation safety. This is a design that obliges nationwide practice to perform a confirmation that confirms nothing about installation safety. It should be revised to a design that confirms information directly linked to grid safety at the same cost (alternative proposal: “minimum duty of care”).
The question phase with IPA will be concluded once the materials needed for the argument are in place. The remaining issues are additional confirmations Q1 to Q18 and supplementary cross-check inquiries Q19 to Q28 to the side advancing the requirements——the Agency for Natural Resources and Energy (public record)——and the submission of comments to the Grid Code Study Group.
6. What can be stated and what cannot be stated
To state definitivelyThe following propositions are stated definitively as facts verifiable from primary sources (IPA responses and IPA public documents).
- “Certification label obtained” does not indicate that it has been safely installed and operated (verbatim from the third response, Q8)
- The effectiveness of the label does not change depending on the installation location (same)
- ★1 is designed to meet the conformity requirements on the premise of receiving direct communications from outside (same)
- All exception routes are not distinguished in the list (second response, Q3; third response, Q11)
- Statistics on exception acquisitions are not disclosed and there are no plans to disclose them (third response, Q12)
- There is no public document that states the criteria for supply chain inquiries (third response, Q13)
- There is no IPA position document on citing ★1 as a legal requirement (Q7 in the second response)
- Accordingly, the grid connection review under the current proposed requirements has a structure in which essentially nothing is checked regarding the safety of the system
Do not make definitive statements The following propositions are not stated definitively.
- That there is dishonesty in IPA's responses and system operation (rather, it is consistently sincere)
- Why the exception measure is improper as a label system (reasonable as market fairness consideration for a voluntary label. The problem is its repurposing into a mandatory requirement)
- Legal recognition of intent to exclude (the administrative side, which should disclose the criteria, bears responsibility for explaining differences in outcomes)
- That JC-STAR ★1 is ineffective (the lower bound of product hygiene and international mutual recognition are acknowledged as facts)
7. Citation and reuse
The 19 questions in the three responses from the IPA Security Center Technical Evaluation Division cited in this article are published under CC BY 4.0 as question-by-question CSV files and public-use reproductions of the originals (PDF). They may be freely used, including for redistribution, modification, and commercial use, as long as I-S3 Co., Ltd. and the URL of this article are clearly stated as the source. Copyright in the response text belongs to each administrative agency, and the CSV files organize the received responses by question. The names, email addresses, and phone numbers of the administrative staff have been replaced with [omitted], while the department name, date received, and response text remain unchanged.
The text and figures may be quoted as is, provided the source is clearly stated. For reproduction or redistribution of figures and tables, please contact inquiries. If you have a different interpretation of how to read the responses, please use the same contact point. If the basis is shown, it will be added to the text.
Data file
ipa_replies.csv— IPA Security Center, Technical Evaluation Division responses, 19 questions over 3 roundsmeti_answers_28.csv— Agency for Natural Resources and Energy, Electricity Infrastructure Division: Answers to all 28 questions (attached to the ANRE 28-question article)README.txt— Column meanings, publication scope, and license
Original public copy
This is a copy of the received email body with only the names, email addresses, and phone numbers of the government-side staff members replaced with [ ... omitted ]. The number of replacements is in MASKING.md.
ipa_reply1_20260719_masked.pdf— IPA 1st response email (2026-07-19)ipa_reply2_20260725_masked.pdf— IPA 2nd response email (2026-07-25)ipa_reply3_20260726_masked.pdf— IPA 3rd response email (2026-07-26)MASKING.md— Masking record (what was redacted)
recommended citation format
Japanese text
益田周防海(2026)「ラベルは「安全に設置・運用」を示さない— IPA第3回答で確定したこととテーマまとめ」株式会社I-S3、2026年7月26日公開、https://www.i-s3.com/jc-star-ipa-reply3-analysis-20260726.html
English
Masuda, S. (2026). ラベルは「安全に設置・運用」を示さない— IPA第3回答で確定したこととテーマまとめ. I-S3 Co., Ltd. https://www.i-s3.com/jc-star-ipa-reply3-analysis-20260726.html
BibTeX
@misc{masuda2026jcstar_ipa_20260726,
author = {Masuda, Suomi},
title = {ラベルは「安全に設置・運用」を示さない— IPA第3回答で確定したこととテーマまとめ},
year = {2026},
publisher = {I-S3 Co., Ltd.},
url = {https://www.i-s3.com/jc-star-ipa-reply3-analysis-20260726.html},
note = {Published 2026-07-26. Q\&A dataset (CSV, CC BY 4.0): https://www.i-s3.com/jc-star-answers/}
}
revision history
- October 6, 2026: Added the citation and reuse section, and published the responses as a question-by-question CSV and an original public copy (CC BY 4.0).